Angel 4×09: Long Day’s Journey

[Review by Robert Taylor]

[Writer: Mere Smith | Director: Terrence O Hara | Aired: 01/22/2003]

“Long Day’s Journey” represents the tipping point for “Angel’s” fourth season, setting up the multi-episode Angelus arc while meticulously teasing viewers with new mysteries (in this case a literal locked-room mystery). But more than anything, what crystallizes here for viewers is the impression that the show’s writers are now fully working without a net. Much has been written (both on this site and elsewhere) about the creative difficulties the staff had in mapping out the Season 4 overall storyline (multiple showrunner exits, Charisma Carpenter’s pregnancy, etc.), and while the “making it up as we go along” aspect to storytelling can (and, elsewhere, does) result in plot holes and viewer annoyance, in this episode and the other great ones of Season 4 there’s a real excitement to the ride. You don’t know if the writers know where they are going, but for the moment it’s too enjoyable to matter.

The show’s title, “Long Day’s Journey,” apes on the Eugene O’Neill classic play “Long Day’s Journey Into Night.” And though it works on a literal level (the Beast is planning on throwing Los Angeles into eternal night), it also tips its hat to O’Neill’s characters—a family whose mistakes, hidden motives and inability to control emotion results in their eventual implosion. Sound familiar? As the episode opens, we wonder if Angel’s “family” unit can become any more divided than it already is (those who have watched the remainder of the season will answer with a resounding “Um, duh!”). Cordelia (or should I say “Cordelia”) has boinked Connor. Angel, uh, watched the whole thing unfold and told Cordelia he knows everything. Gunn still hates Wesley, who still loves Fred, and as a result Fred is pulling away from Gunn. And Lorne’s desperate attempts to bring the group together seem just that: desperate.

The episode opens with us revisiting the character of Gwen Raiden, cat-thief extraordinaire. This installment’s writer, Mere Smith, also penned Gwen’s introduction in “Ground State” [4×02]. Upon first glance, Gwen had all the hallmarks of one of Joss Whedon’s signature strong female creations, but she didn’t seem to click with viewers or the writers and only made three appearances before disappearing into the ether. Perhaps it was that her powers (the touch of her skin creates an electric shock) were too explicit. Perhaps it was that her character was introduced right before what is essentially a supernatural season-long mirror of “24,” and she’s not a puzzle piece that easily fits into that tone. Perhaps it was that her character is cut from the same cloth as Lilah, but thirty percent less evil and therefore less engaging. Perhaps it was the spandex. Whatever the case, she’s not a bad character, just one who didn’t catch on. She functions well within the episode itself on several levels: She is a romantic foil Angel uses to make Cordelia jealous, she serves as a suspect in the locked-room mystery, and she is an outside voice in an ever-more-claustrophobic series.

Speaking of Cordy, viewers were still in the process of picking their jaws off the floor two episodes after she slept with Connor. While the previous episode, the pun-ily titled “Habeas Corpses” [4×08], focused almost exclusively on the emotional slap-to-the-face the sex was to Angel, “Long Day’s Journey” seems more interested in exploring Cordelia’s point-of-view. Of course, in retrospect, we know that it’s not the “real” Cordelia in her scenes, but I think this is probably the first episode that plays fair with both her classic characterization and her ulterior motives. The entire idea of Connor having sex with his surrogate mother is the definition of an Oedipal complex, but writer Smith rightly goes to extremes to downplay that here (later episodes, most notably “Orpheus” [4×15] and “Inside Out” [4×17] would go to extremes to exploit it) in an attempt to get viewers to feel some sort of attachment to Cordelia once more. Her dialogue “sounds” more like Cordelia than any episode since the Smith-penned “Birthday” [3×11] (yes, “Spin The Bottle” [4×06] featured a heavy dose of high-school-brand Cordy, but it was imposed by a spell). And her blunt accusations of Gwen after she was apparently drugged feel like something the Cordelia of old would do. Angel is again hostile with her in almost every scene they share, rightfully so, and her short moment of entering the hotel and not even knowing how to begin a conversation with the rest of the gang underlines how isolated she must feel because of her mistakes. Once more, in retrospect we understand that she was accusing Gwen to shift the focus onto someone other than herself and her single-mindedness in the hotel was to plant the Angelus seeds into Angel, but the writing is smart enough for them to work on both levels. I would venture so far to write that that “Long Day’s Journey” holds up best among the first thirteen episodes of the season to repeat viewings with the entire arc in mind.

Connor is still just as detestable here as he is in most other episodes. I understand how hurt he is and confused after being deceived for most of his life and blah blah blah. He’s theoretically as complex a character as Angel, but his personality and readiness to become evil at the drop of a hat remains the most frustrating part of the season to this viewer. A touchtone of the season is that characters keep comparing him to Angel and talking about how similar they are (Cordelia and Fred here, Willow in “Orpheus” [4×15]), but that seems to be the writers almost insisting that his actions and motivations are legitimate, even though they mostly serve as nothing more than functions of the plot and to create false suspense that he’ll murder his father. Also, it doesn’t help that every single decision he makes as a character is the wrong one. As the episode opens, he’s showing off like a schoolboy to Cordelia (“I have super-hearing!”) and the moment she brings up Angel he becomes aggressive and tries to challenge her for her affection, all but saying: “Tell me you love me more than him,” something Cordelia is unwilling to do because it would alleviate some of her power over him. Finally, she leaves while sighing, “I trust you, Connor.” I’ll admit that I smiled widely when he gets his ### handed to him at the climax of the episode, but more on that later.

Concerning the Fred/Gunn romance, the only real trace of it left is one quickly spoken “baby” by Gunn early in the episode and his going out of his way to touch Fred when Wesley is nearby, more like an animal keeping one paw on his prey than a lover reaching out to his beloved. By this point each episode had the same small arc for the triangle of Gunn, Fred and Wesley: Fred and Gunn speak more like friends than lovers, there is a small inkling of romance between then, then Wesley enters the room and Gunn pushes up against every sentence that comes out of his mouth, even the logical ones. When Fred ultimately agrees with anything Wesley says, this compounds Gunn’s anger. These beats have been repeated in some form or another since “Spin The Bottle” [4×06]. Ah well, at least Gunn gets a nice scene with Gwen in the episode to talk about something other than…oh wait never mind that scene was all about Fred. Whedon’s shows, in general, seem afraid of allowing a couple any amount of happiness for fear of boredom (later seasons of Buffy and Angel especially underline this), but Whedon’s solution usually involves killing off one of the two.

In Buffy Season 6, Tara got 40 minutes of screen time to be with her true love before she was shot to death in “Seeing Red” [6×19], and in Angel Season 5 Fred gets about ten minutes of happiness with Wesley before she begins dying in “A Hole in the World” [5×15]. Here, Whedon does something more interesting: He removes almost every trace of romance between Fred and Gunn yet keeps them in a “relationship,” slowly letting it die before our eyes by repeating this same cycle until the characters cannot take it anymore. I should also mention that, if the aforementioned jealousy cycle happened multiple times in a series of standalone episodes like the ones from the first three seasons, it would have quickly become unbearable for viewers. But because of the tension, overstuffing and fast pacing of Season 4, the love triangle becomes such a background element that viewers are more willing to see the same beat over and over because it is such a small part of any given episode.

The storyline involves Angel Investigations attempting to protect the final member of the Ra-tet. The Beast is removing a piece from each one of their bodies in order to create a device that will plunge Los Angeles into darkness. Angel gets his hands on the last member, named Manny as short for Man-jit, who dresses a lot like Doyle used to dress. This is probably the only tip-of-the-hat to the just-deceased Glenn Quinn, who the episode is dedicated in loving memory to. In order to keep Manny safe, Gwen offers up her hideout, which is a really cool piece of real estate. On the outside it looks like an abandoned warehouse, but once you go through a door it looks like Downton Abbey. There’s even a panic room you access through pulling the correct book off a shelf (“Never pass up a good cliché,” Gwen smiles as she opens the room). It’s here that Angel and Cordelia are drugged through their evening beverages and, when they awaken, Manny has been murdered and mutilated. Of course we ultimately know it’s Cordelia who did the deed, but Smith does a wonderful job of planting red herrings with Gwen, Connor and finally implying that Angelus somehow took over Angel and killed Manny.

At the center of it is Angel, who is a live wire of emotion. Lorne tries to snap him out of it at the beginning of the episode, but it doesn’t work. Rightly incensed that his second true love slept with his son, he continues to take it almost exclusively out on Cordelia, though one would imagine he would also be at least a little cross with Connor about it. Ah well, after all the crap his son has pulled and all the excuses Connor found to try and kill his dad, sleeping with Cordy must have seemed like par for the course. There’s a beautiful moment at the midpoint where Angel tries to give a motivational speech to the troops about fighting the Beast, and what comes out is the motivational equivalent of a loud burp in church. It’s brilliant, and Boreanaz pulls off the moment beautifully instead of allowing it to turn cheestastic. The hero is probably as lost as he ever has been in the series, rivaled only by sleeping with Darla in “Reprise” [2×15], and his friends are too lost and divided themselves to prop him up. Even after spending the summer on the bottom of the ocean he could turn on the hero button quickly, but not here. Not now. And we fully understand why, which makes it all the more tragic.

If the characterization and episode pacing make this episode transcendent, I have to admit that the final five minutes are a bit of a repeat beat from “Apocalypse, Nowish” [4×07]. In both, the gang just wail away on the Beast while not actually doing any damage, and both end with an apocalyptic event (fire raining from the sky in the first, the sun being blotted out in the second). I have no problem with the first part, because it’s always a joy to see “tough” Connor getting thrown around, but on a story level because it’s important for the writers to underline just how out of their depth team Angel really is. It also shows how divided the team is at this point in the story, unable to work together well even when sharing the field of battle together. Multiple lost battles are fine, but the sun being blotted out is too repetitious, especially considering that, while it’s a really cool visual, it has little to no emotional effect on our heroes. I should also note that the stunts and wire work in this sequence (aside from the stunt of Connor being thrown out of the window, which is aces) are some of the worst in series history, with the Beast’s final exit apparently so bad that they cut it down to four frames. What we can see of it looks like something out of a Godzilla movie.

This is probably the closest thing we have to a “filler” episode through this entire Beast/Angelus/Jasmine arc, but what a filler episode it is! Smack dab between the epic shenanigans over at Wolfram & Hart and Angelus being awakened, there is room for contemplation here. While watching the episode, you feel the writers trying to figure out the story as much as we are, and there’s something very exciting about that. The episode is evenly paced and has some great dialogue from almost every character. It’s also one that is genuinely easy to re-watch considering evil Cordelia’s involvement in the whole shebang, and seeing Connor pummeled is just a bonus.


Minor Pros/Cons (+/-)

+ Lorne’s opening impassioned speech to Angel, practically begging him to become a leader again.
+ The gorgeous, “Haxan”-style flashbacks/memories of the Beast speaking to Angelus.
+ The exterior photographs used as mattes for Connor’s apartment don’t even come close to matching the exterior shots in the final act.

– The Demon flying off like Godzilla to escape.
– The lack of Lilah.


* Cordelia insists on going with Angel to Gwen’s hideaway. When we find out she is the Beast’s Master, we realize she did it so she could kill him herself.




20 thoughts on “Angel 4×09: Long Day’s Journey”

  1. [Note: MikeJer posted this comment on September 26, 2012.]

    I like your character observations, and you’re right to point out how — at least in isolation — this plot and “Cordelia’s” involvement make sense even through the retrospective lens.My problem lies mostly with the fact that the plot ends up being a cog in a larger plot that is quite aimless and incoherent.A couple other thoughts:1. In response to your opening paragraph, doesn’t coming from a retrospective angle — where that “ride” isn’t as coherent as we might have initially thought when first watching it — taint how this episode feels to you? I know it does for me. With that perspective, “Long Day’s Journey” feels rather plot-heavy, best shown in the moments after the Beast succeeds at the end. The characters all feel like plot-puppets in the grand scheme of things, and it’s for the sake of a larger plot doesn’t even turn out to be very coherent. 2. I find the repeated Gunn/Fred/Wesley beat beyond tiring in Season 4. The first time I watched the season, it didn’t bother me as much, but this beat does not hold up to repeated viewings at all. So I guess I’ll just say that it doesn’t work for me here, unfortunately.In all, I personally find this episode to be on the weak side, but you’ve definitely pointed out some of its strengths quite nicely, so it’s certainly not a total loss by any means.Thanks for the review! 😀


  2. [Note: buffyholic posted this comment on September 27, 2012.]

    Very nice review. You made a great point discussing all the pros and cons of this episode. I really, really like this episode because it goes with one of the best things that season four has, at least for me: a sense of doom and gloom and having every character mistrust each other.And finally, good insight on Fred/Gunn. I never saw their romance as having “a slow death” but I can definitively see it.


  3. [Note: fray-adjacent posted this comment on September 27, 2012.]

    Very nice review, Robert! One thing that jumped out at me about your review overall is that you focused on the visual aspects more than most CT reviewers do. As someone who is increasingly appreciating those aspects of film, both on their own aesthetic merit and for how they add to or detract from story, theme, and character development, but who generally lacks the vocabulary to critique visuals, it was cool to read that. I also like that we each can bring our own preferences in what elements of the episode we give weight to, but still stay within the general character/emotion focused framework that MikeJer established.OK, to the content of the review itself. I confess I haven’t watched this episode in quite a long time, and a big reason for that is that I didn’t care for it too much. Not that I hated it, but it never was a standout even in S4 for me. I’m looking forward to re-reading your review next time to watch it to see how my views might change in light of your points.I very much agree that Cordelia is written better here than in most episodes. What appears to be believable jealousy and suspicion of Gwen is later revealed to be fear that Gwen will thwart “Cordelia’s” evil plans.Like Buffyholic, I hadn’t recognized how different Fred and Gunn’s “slow death” was from other relationships ending in Whedon shows. Actually, the first time I watched Angel I was sure they’d kill off one of them — I was betting on Gunn because I’d heard references to Fred getting together with Wesley later on. It’s interesting that they went this route, and points to the value of *not* killing off characters for the sake of immediate drama, because you can do great things with them later. 🙂


  4. [Note: fray-adjacent posted this comment on September 27, 2012.]

    By the way, when I said that “Cordelia is written better here than in most episodes”, I meant most episodes in Season 4.


  5. [Note: wytchcroft posted this comment on September 28, 2012.]

    Very interesting review!Like a lot of others, i have to confess to often forgetting about this episode and you cover a lot of good reasons (visually and thematically) as to why i shouldn’t.I must disagree about Connor being simply ‘detestable’ – you may not like the character or the actor but that seems a little too sweeping a statement. Myself, i always liked both. Horses for courses i guess.


  6. [Note: Anonymous posted this comment on October 5, 2012.]

    What about the “lack of Lilah” made it a con? Did it feel like she was needed for the plot or that her absence was suspicious? If it was just because Lilah is a fan favorite, and you wished there was more of her, then that just doesn’t seem right to consider it a con. Sort of like how I enjoy Drusilla, yet I wouldn’t consider any episode without her (or at the very least, a BTVS Season 2 episode) a con in that area.


  7. [Note: Robert Taylor posted this comment on October 7, 2012.]

    Hello Anonymous,I think Lilah could have added to the mystery elements of the plot by adding in another suspect to the mix, which is why I noted her absence.


  8. [Note: SueB posted this comment on October 9, 2012.]

    I think you missed the point of Connor talking about his superpowers – he’s talking about himself being unnatural. About being connected to the Beast. He’s not actually bragging. The delivery is off so I can see your interpretation but the dialog is pretty clear – he’s worried about being responsible for what is going on. He wants to know where these powers came from (why he went to Lilah) and what the Beast wants with him. The Beast called him “Connor” by name at W&H and again in this episode. Note: the Beast only beating Connor up and not killing him is nice foreshadowing of Connor and Cordelia needing to be protected as they are Jasmine’s tether to this world.


  9. [Note: Dave posted this comment on November 19, 2012.]

    Anyone seen the Avengers? How the Beast slams Connor into the ground by his leg is exactly how the Hulk slams Loki.


  10. [Note: Ryan ONeil posted this comment on November 20, 2012.]

    Yes, Joss Whedon does a lot of references to The Avengers in Buffy and AngelCOMPLETELY BY ACCIDENT because he had no idea that he would get to be the one to eventually make the movie!:) 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂


  11. [Note: B posted this comment on October 25, 2014.]

    This season is best watched in succession. When viewed as it was originally aired it’s hard to follow ans seems like a jumbled mess. The only complaint I have with this season the mishandling of Cordelia. Her being possessed I can get but her relationship with Connor is icky. I wish the real Cordy would have awoken and given her life to stop Jasminr, giving Angel a kiss before she does so and saying Guess we’ll never know if I could have given you a moment of perfect happiness


  12. [Note: B posted this comment on October 25, 2014.]

    I think this season gets a bad rap that it doesn’t deserve. I know the writers struggled with how to handle Charisma’s pregnancy but other than her relationship with Connor it’s a well done season.


  13. [Note: Kyle posted this comment on October 25, 2014.]

    The problem with this season is its over-intense focus on plot rather than character development. The plot really wasn’t even that good, as it had too many holes and inconsistencies. Also, many of the plot lines seemed to kind of sit there for a while and then one episode (“Orpheus” for example) would take almost every single one of them up (way too many) and try and resolve them, failing to do so with many. Episodes like “Long Day’s Journey” didn’t really do much to advance character arcs as they spent more time on advancing the plot. Season 4 seemed to be all about plot, plot, plot… Plot that wasn’t even that great.

    While season 4 had some very interesting ideas, it didn’t execute them well, as exemplified by the Jasmine arc. The ideas presented in that arc were quite interesting. However, they failed to hold my attention for very long because the execution was, frankly, way over the top and quite cheesy.

    Other than the first season of Buffy, season 4 of Angel was probably the weakest season of the Buffyverse.


  14. [Note: Freudian Vampire posted this comment on October 25, 2014.]

    I have trouble identifying Angel‘s fourth season as one of the worst of the ‘verse because, while it’s flaws were crippling, it did contain what I consider to be some of the best material Joss Whedon has ever created. The Connor and Cordelia ugliness is redeemed by Wesley and Lilah; the disappointment of Angelus counteracted by the awesomeness that is Faith. The first and third seasons of Angel were more consistent than the fourth, but lacked such heady heights, and the seventh season of Buffy was, in my view, just plain bad.

    That said, I wholly agree with you with regards to the plot, “Orpheus”, “Long Day’s Journey” and Jasmine, all of which epitomized the failings of the writing this season and represent some of the greatest missteps Joss Whedon has ever made.


  15. [Note: Kyle posted this comment on October 25, 2014.]

    I don’t know… A lot of the reason I think of the fourth season of Angel as bad is because I just don’t like it. Add on top of that its inconsistencies and, yeah, I’m going to label it was one of the verse’s worst seasons. Also, the characters become a lot less likable in Angel from the end of the third season all the way through the end of the fourth season.

    As for the first and third seasons of Angel, I can agree that the first season is more consistent but failed to carry itself to more exciting heights; however, I have to say that season 3 is both just as inconsistent and emotionally thrilling as season 4. I just think season 3 is a little better than season 4. Also, I disagree with your view of the seventh season of Buffy. Aside from season 1, it is the most flawed season of Buffy, but it has enough good episodes, character development, ambition, and potent moments to elevate it above the fourth season of Angel.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s